How to Revive Dead Leads (Without Being Pushy)

Quick recap:

• Two weeks ago we talked about tracking your client pipeline (read here).
• Last week was all about filling it with Hot Prospects, aka your former clients and mentors (read here).

This week, we're moving on to the next tier: Warm Prospects.

These are people you've already had sales conversations with but never closed. Maybe you sent them a proposal and they ghosted. Maybe you had a discovery call that went nowhere. Maybe timing wasn't right.

Most freelancers write these off as dead leads and move on.

That's a mistake.

‍

The Leads You're Leaving on the Table

Here's what usually happens:

You have a great discovery call. The prospect seems interested. You send a proposal. Then... silence.

You follow up once. Maybe twice. Still nothing.

So you assume they went with someone else, they don't have budget, or they're just not interested. You move on.

But here's the reality: most of the time, they didn't say no. They just got busy. Priorities shifted. The project got pushed. Someone internally dropped the ball.

They're not dead leads. They're warm leads that went cold.

And with the right approach, you can bring them back to life.

‍

Why Warm Prospects Are Worth Your Time

I've closed deals 6 months after the initial conversation went cold. Sometimes a year later.

The prospect never forgot about me. They just needed a reason to re-engage.

Here's what makes Warm Prospects valuable:

They already know what you do. You've explained your services. They understand your value. You don't need to start from scratch.

They showed interest once. At some point, they thought you could help them. That interest doesn't disappear, it just gets buried under other priorities.

The timing might be better now. Maybe budget freed up. Maybe the pain point got worse. Maybe the person who was handling it internally quit. Things change.

All you need to do is give them a reason to re-engage.

‍

How to Follow Up Without Being Annoying

The key is leading with value, not desperation.

You're not saying "hey, just checking in!" or "did you get my proposal?"

You're bringing them something new. A recent win. A relevant insight. Proof that you're still the right person for the job.

Here are the two approaches that work.

Template 1: Old Leads Who Received Your Proposal (The Non-Pushy Push)

Use this when you sent a proposal but they never responded.

Subject: Circling back on [their project/goal]

Hi [Name],

I know we talked about [specific project: revamping your paid social strategy/improving your site's conversion rates/etc.] back in [timeframe], and timing wasn't quite right then.

Circling back because I just wrapped something similar for [Company/Industry]. They were dealing with [problem similar to prospect's], and we [specific result with numbers: increased qualified demo bookings by 240%/cut cost-per-lead from $180 to $65/etc.] in [timeframe].

[Optional: One sentence about what made it work]

No pressure at all, but if you're still looking to [their original goal], I'd be happy to share what we learned from this that might apply to [their company]. Could even do a quick 15-min call to see if there's a fit.

Let me know if you'd find that valuable.

Best,
[Your name]

‍

Why this works: You're not asking "did you forget about me?" You're showing them you just crushed it for someone with their exact problem. That re-establishes your credibility and gives them a reason to reply.

‍

Template 2: Old Leads Who Never Got to Proposal Stage (The Value-Forward Check-In)

Use this when the conversation died before you even sent a proposal.

Subject: Following up on [their project]

Hey [Name],

We chatted back in [timeframe] about [specific challenge they mentioned: improving your organic visibility/scaling your ad accounts/etc.].

I realized I never followed up to see what you ended up doing. Did you move forward with [the project/a solution]? How did it go?

I've been working with a few companies in [their industry] on similar challenges lately, and we've been seeing [specific pattern/result]. Made me think of our conversation.

If you're still working on [their goal] or if things didn't quite work out the way you'd hoped, I'd be happy to share what's been working lately. Could do a quick audit or just hop on a brief call, whatever's most useful.

No worries either way, just wanted to check in.

Best,
[Your name]

‍

Why this works: You're genuinely curious about what happened. You're offering help without asking for anything. And you're positioning yourself as someone who's been actively working on their exact problem.

‍

The Old Freelancer Way vs. The Modern Freelancer Way

The old freelancer:

• Follow up once or twice, then give up
• Assume if they were interested, they would have replied
• Write off old leads as lost opportunities

The Modern Freelancer:

• Follow up with new value, not just "checking in"
• Understand that timing matters more than interest
• Treat warm leads as an ongoing pipeline, not a one-time shot

‍

Your Action Step

This week:

1. Open your Sales Pipeline Tracker and find 3-5 Warm Prospects: people you had sales conversations with in the past 6-12 months who never closed
   
2. Pick one person and send them a message using Template 1 or Template 2 (depending on whether you sent a proposal or not)
   
3. Track the outreach in your pipeline and set a reminder to follow up again in 5 days if they don't respond
   

Remember: you're not being pushy. You're being persistent. There's a difference.

Next Friday, I'm showing you how to fill your pipeline with Cold Prospects. These are people you've never spoken to before, connections you haven't engaged with in 6+ months, or LinkedIn contacts from old networking events. Different tier, different strategy.

We're building a complete system here. Next week, we'll cover how to turn LinkedIn connections into paying clients.

--

I write a free newsletter where I send out actionable freelance marketing tips. If you want to keep an edge and stand out in the increasingly competitive freelance landscape, consider signing up.